The challenge
of conducting research on large and important cities is that the significance
of any given city is defined very differently by the authors of various studies.
This divergence of views reflects both the diverse nature of cities and also
differences of approach taken in the study of cities. In this section, we
provide a short overview of the different understandings of the significance
of large cities by introducing the terms world city, global city,
informational city, mega city, and global city-region.
Of course this is only a narrow selection made from a wide range of terms
used to describe cities. However, in the context of our own study on Global
City Regions as Changing Sites of Governance, we consider the following
definitions to be extremely valuable for developing a framework of analysis.
Research
on global cities or city regions can be traced back to the world cities idea of Hall (1966) and Friedman and Wolff (1982), and
also to Sassen's conception of global
cities (1991).
Hall (1966) [4] defines world
cities in terms of their multiple roles: “They [are] centres of political
power, both national and international, and of the organizations related to
government; centres of national and international trade and all kinds of economic
activity, acting as entrepôts for their countries and sometimes for neighbouring
countries also”.
Sassen
(1991) defines global cities as, "cities that are
strategic sites in the global economy because of their concentration of command
functions and high-level producer service firms oriented to world markets;
more generally cities with high levels of internationalisation in their economy
and in their broader social structure" [6]. Thus, they are both centres
of production and innovation as well as a home to markets.
The
mega city concept is based on quantitative
criterion assessing total population size. With respect to the quantitative
definition used by the United Nations (1991), it refers to agglomerations with a minimum population
size of more than 8 millions inhabitants. Other authors refer to the minimum
number of 10 million. The concept has been frequently criticized for only
considering the sheer size of the population, which may not guarantee any
qualitative differences compared to smaller cities as regards economic performance
and the role as a node and hub in a global network of cities.
The
main purpose of the “Globalization and World Cities Study Group and Network”
(GaWC) at Loughborough University is to produce an inventory of world cities
in terms of their provision of corporate services. The basic unit of analysis
in this assessment is the service firm. For any given city GaWC is looking
at the presence of major corporate service firms. “By studying several firms
over many cities, we are able to obtain the relative importance of a given
city in terms of a particular service. By carrying out this exercise for several
services, we can evaluate the overall ‘world-cityness’ of a given city.” [8]
Last but not least, a global city region is a geographic area with a city as its centre that has strong impact on the global city region’s growth and development. As Allen Scott, representative of the so called L.A. school, states, a global city region is “any metropolitan area or any contiguous set of metropolitan areas together with a surrounding hinterland of variable extent – itself a locus of scattered urban settlements – whose internal economic and political affairs are bound up in intricate ways in intensifying and far-flung extra-national relationships.” [9] The growing extension and diffusion of global cities, forming a vast arrey and a corpus of at least partly marginalized suburbanity called for the establishment of this new term.
[4] Vgl. Hall, Peter (1966): The World Cities. London, hier zitiert aus dem Internet: <http://www.megacities.nl/lecture_hall.htm>.
[5] Friedman, John Friedman; Wolff, Goetz (1982):
„World City Formation: An Agenda for Research and Action“, International
Journal of Urban and Regional Research. Vol. 6, no. 2: p. 319.
[6] Sassen, Saskia (1991): The Global City: New York,
London, Tokyo. Princeton. In the Internet: http://www.india-seminar.com/2001/503/503%20saskia%20sassen.htm.
[7] Castells, Manuel (1989): The Informational City.
Information, Technology, Economic Restructuring and the Urban-Regional Process.
Oxford.
[8] J.V. Beaverstock, R.G. Smith and P.J. Taylor
(1999): A Roster of World Cities, in:Cities, 16 (6), (1999), 445-458, in
the Internet: http://www.lboro.ac.uk/gawc/rb/rb5.html
[9] Scott, Alan J. (ed.)(2001): Global City regions.
Trend, Theory, Policy. Oxford, see p. 11. In the Internet: http://www2.ucsc.edu/cgirs/publications/cpapers/scott.pdf.